Well, we’ve had our own Columbine here in downtown Portland, and while there’s been lots of information about the promising young lives the shooter snuffed out or did irreperable damage to, there hasn’t been a whole lot of detail about him, save that he was a “student of concern” at his high school, had been “depressed and on medication” and was calm and provided proper documentation when buying his gun at a Tigard store. And, as seems to be the case with most mass murderers, his neighbors didn’t know him very well and didn’t sense anything amiss. He was “quiet”. His former employers rated him highly although the woman in the neighboring cubicle found him “peculiar” and complained to no avail.
No one accepts blame yet so many deserve it.
I can’t blame the owner of the gun shop–who, to his credit, admits feeling guilt–but I do blame the laws under which he operates. Gun ownership is legal in this country. I admit the eight years of the Bush administration have weakened my opposition to the Second Amendment. Should Cheney et al have staged a military coup, I would have regretted not owning a gun. I couldn’t get it out of my mind that in prewar Germany Jews, unlike their Christian countrymen, did not own guns. Nevertheless, some degree of restriction is necessary for public safety. To drive a car, a device with the capacity to be a lethal weapon, you need to take lessons, prove your capability to drive, have your vision tested, renew the license periodically with further testing, and present twenty zillion kinds of ID. Surely to buying a gun, whose sole purpose is as a lethal weapon, should require a comparable degree of proof of responsibility? Not in this country.
Some say that these restrictions could be readily evaded by criminals, as evidenced by the saying “if guns are outlawed only outlaws will have guns”. That’s probably true. I’m sure the Mafia would still manage to get the weapons they needed. Drug dealers shouldn’t have any more trouble obtaining illegal weapons than they do illegal substances. But it would be a lot harder for psychopaths to buy guns, and they’re a lot more likely to kill innocent people.
In Oregon–and this is a recent development–gun buyers are required to prove they haven’t been convicted of a felony or committed to a mental institution. They don’t need to reveal whether they’ve ever been treated for mental illness. That’s protected by “privacy laws”. While privacy laws were enacted in response to legitimate abuse, and while a history of mental illness is irrelevant for many purposes–bank loans and most employment, to name a couple–it is relevant to the purchase of a gun.
And as for the committment to a mental institution, business, forget it. As anyone whose had contact with what passes for our mental health system knows, you can’t even commit yourself voluntarily to a mental ward unless you are a “danger to oneself and others”. It doesn’t matter if you, or someone you love, are standing there in the emergency room babbling that God is telling you to murder the infidels. You’ve got to literally shove that knife up to somebody’s throat.
I don’t know what the problem is. I don’t know if health personnel are more afraid of legal liability than mad gunmen, or whether it runs even deeper than that and they are terrified of the personal risk and accountability they incur when they reach beyond the letter of the law and accept responsibility for another human being. We are very protective, as Americans, of the right of people to destroy themselves. That’s why troubled people are not enclosed within a circle of protection, why they are set adrift to live in anonymous apartments and play video games and work temp jobs and be “quiet”–until they’re not. When people destroy themselves, they all too often take innocent others along with them.
I realize there is no specific person to blame. Our fascination with firearms is to blame. Our atomized society is to blame. Our reliance on law and regulation as a substitute for responsibility to the human community is to blame. All the people who encountered the troubled Erik Ayala and passed the buck can now breathe a sigh of relief that they are free of legal liability. He’s proved beyond a doubt that he’s a danger to himself and others. Too bad that he and the others are dead.