Last week, during a chaotic yet joyful visit, my brother showed me a book he’d recently bought, entitled something on the order of “optimum mess”. The basic thesis of the book was that neater and more organized is not always better. Hyperneatness and organization carry their own efficiency cost. Most systems, business or personal, operate most effectively at an optimum level of mess. The key is to find that level.
I’ve been thinking about that book as I organize my house, office, and life for the new year. Periodically, I am beset by such urges, usually when its gray and cold, leaving me indoors and face to face with the mess. I am sloppy by nature. Clean but sloppy. Papers pile up, balls of yarn tangle, unread magazines overflow their basket, legos appear in the most mysterious of places.
Complicating the situation is the fact that I am a fan of the ornate, the complicated, the abundant. I know people who have stripped down, Zen-like houses and seemingly stripped-down lives, but their brain cells must fire in a radically different way. My taste in home decoration is my taste in novels is my taste in life: gothic and overgrown, full of history, mysterious pathways, and surprises. My ideal is organized creative chaos. (Yes, I know there’s an inherent contradiction there)
The optimum mess theory counters the conventional wisdom that you should purge your possessions with relentless regularity. You never know, they say, when an article in a year old copy of Harper’s might trigger a life-altering revelation, or that bustier from the eighties might prove the perfect thing to wear to a party, or that old record album might be worth $10,00o on EBay. In truth, on the rare occasions when I’ve made the conscious decision to throw anything other than overt garbage away, I’ve usually regretted it. Before my marriage and subsequent move to Chicago, I went through a giant pile of childhood memorabilia. One thing I threw away was a collection of looseleaf notebooks containing canned food labels given to me by my Grandpa Barney, a canned food salesman. Not only were these labels my only tangible heirloom from my Grandfather, I now see labels like them framed and sold for considerable sums at antique stores.
It’s that ideal of organization that drives these wintertime household frenzies. My mind is as full of projects as my house is with stuff. If only I was perfectly organized, I think, I would finish those three screenplays, sew that quilt, knit that flowered bag, grow twenty varieties of heirloom tomatoes, practice the piano, read every issue of the zillions of magazines I subscribe to, cook a new recipe daily, and call my congressman every time Move On sent me an email.
So I’m trying. Last fall I sorted my yarns by color and texture and placed them in attractive cubicles. I organized all my free lance article projects in metal files, and when I finish an article I save it on the computer, and throw out all those little post-it notes. I picked up my son’s hundreds of pieces of Playmobil from where they sat jumbled by his closet, blocking his access to his own impressive collection of children’s magazines. Together, we reassembled the Playmobil in his brother’s room, which had been sitting large and empty since he left for college.
Playmobil is made in Germany, and each set comes with intricate instructions for assembly, down to miniature sailor’s knots for the pirate ship and snowshoes for the Arctic explorer. We both love Playmobil in all its complexity, and each time we buy a new one we assemble it carefully and painstakingly according to instructions. (I even keep the instructions in a file). But then the castle or iceberg inevitably gets bumped into or simply enthusiastically played with, and collapses. I have no idea how to put them back together again (don’t ask me to get the instructions out of the file).
In our reconstructed Playmobil universe, lions romp on the iceberg and pirates wear armor. Monkeys hang from the bakery walls and cows make friends with the polar bear. You never know what unlikely incongruity you’ll dream up next.
Now that’s optimum mess.